Skip to main content

HB139 Alabama 2011 Session

Updated Feb 27, 2026
High Interest

Summary

Primary Sponsor
Arthur Payne
Arthur Payne
Republican
Session
Regular Session 2011
Title
Criminal defendants, youthful offender status, persons charged with a crime involving intentional serious physical injury or death not eligible, Sec. 15-19-1 am'd.
Summary

HB139 would bar youthful offender status for minors charged with crimes that include intentionally inflicted serious physical injury or intentionally killed the victim as an element of the crime.

What This Bill Does

The bill changes current rules by adding a clear prohibition: if the charged crime includes as an element that the defendant intentionally inflicted serious physical injury or intentionally killed the victim, the defendant cannot be granted youthful offender status. It keeps the existing framework for other crimes where youthful offender status could still be considered. The law would apply when deciding eligibility for youthful offender status in cases involving minors.

Who It Affects
  • Minors charged with crimes that include as an element the intentional infliction of serious physical injury or the intentional killing of a victim, who would no longer be eligible for youthful offender status.
  • Judicial and prosecutorial teams handling youthful offender determinations, who would must apply the new eligibility rule when evaluating such cases.
Key Provisions
  • Amends Section 15-19-1 to add a prohibition: a person charged with a crime that contains an element or allegation of intentional serious physical injury or intentional killing cannot be granted youthful offender status.
  • The act becomes effective on the first day of the third month after its passage and approval.
AI-generated summary using openai/gpt-5-nano on Feb 24, 2026. May contain errors — refer to the official bill text for accuracy.
Subjects
Crimes and Offenses

Bill Actions

Pending third reading on day 28 Favorable from Judiciary with 1 amendment

Judiciary first Amendment Offered

Read for the second time and placed on the calendar 1 amendment

Read for the first time and referred to the Senate committee on Judiciary

Engrossed

Motion to Read a Third Time and Pass adopted Roll Call 801

Motion to Adopt adopted Roll Call 800

England Amendment Offered

Payne motion to Table lost Roll Call 799

Motion to Adopt adopted Roll Call 798

Judiciary Amendment Offered

Third Reading Passed

Read for the second time and placed on the calendar 1 amendment

Read for the first time and referred to the House of Representatives committee on Judiciary

Bill Text

Votes

Motion to Read a Third Time and Pass

May 24, 2011 House Passed
Yes 92
No 7
Abstained 1
Absent 5

Payne motion to Table

May 24, 2011 House Failed
Yes 45
No 51
Abstained 2
Absent 7

Motion to Adopt

May 24, 2011 House Passed
Yes 75
No 11
Abstained 3
Absent 16

Documents

Source: Alabama Legislature