Senate Judiciary Hearing
Room 325 at 08:30:00
Under existing law, a peace officer is protected from tort liability arising out of his or her conduct in performance of any discretionary function within the line and scope of his or her law enforcement duties.
Under court precedents interpreting existing law, a peace officer is not entitled to this protection when he or she acts willfully, maliciously, fraudulently, in bad faith, beyond his or her authority, or under a mistaken interpretation of the law.
This bill would repeal existing law concerning peace officer immunity and establish a new form of legal protection for law enforcement officers. This new protection would foreclose any claim that seeks to impose civil liability against a law enforcement officer premised on conduct performed within his or her discretionary authority unless: (1) the law enforcement officer acted recklessly without law enforcement justification or (2) the conduct violated a clearly established state or federal statutory or constitutional right of the plaintiff. This bill would also establish a heightened pleading standard and an HB202 INTRODUCED automatic stay of proceedings to remain in effect while the law enforcement officer seeks to establish that the protection applies.
This bill would also provide that a law enforcement officer is justified in, and immune from criminal prosecution for, the use of physical force against a person in the performance of conduct within his or her discretionary authority unless the use of force violates the person’s constitutional rights to be free from excessive force. The bill would entitle a law enforcement officer to a pretrial hearing to establish the applicability of this protection. The bill would also provide for an automatic stay of any criminal prosecution while the law enforcement officer seeks to establish that the protection applies.
Enacted
Enacted
Delivered to Governor
Signature Requested
Enrolled
Ready to Enroll
Reynolds Concur In and Adopt - Adopted Roll Call 1246
Stadthagen Previous Question - Adopted Roll Call 1245
Motion to Read a Third Time and Pass as Amended - Adopted Roll Call 1085
Smitherman motion to Adopt - Lost Roll Call 1084 9J1NYBB-1
Smitherman 1st Amendment Offered 9J1NYBB-1
Singleton motion to Adopt - Lost Roll Call 1082 HGAU138-1
Singleton 2nd Amendment Offered HGAU138-1
Singleton motion to Adopt - Adopted Roll Call 1081 2JTL1SK-1
Singleton 1st Amendment Offered 2JTL1SK-1
Bell motion to Adopt - Adopted Roll Call 1080 YMYIA2N-1
Bell 1st Substitute Offered YMYIA2N-1
Bell motion to Table - Adopted Voice Vote DG9RYHH-1
Judiciary 3rd Amendment Offered DG9RYHH-1
Bell motion to Table - Adopted Voice Vote AR164Q7-1
Judiciary 2nd Amendment Offered AR164Q7-1
Bell motion to Table - Adopted Voice Vote 6YPLE11-1
Judiciary 1st Amendment Offered 6YPLE11-1
Read for the Second Time and placed on the Calendar
Reported Out of Committee Second House
Judiciary 3rd Amendment DG9RYHH-1
Judiciary 2nd Amendment AR164Q7-1
Judiciary 1st Amendment 6YPLE11-1
Pending Senate Judiciary
Read for the first time and referred to the Senate Committee on Judiciary
Engrossed
Motion to Add Cosponsor - Adopted Roll Call 365
Motion to Read a Third Time and Pass as Amended - Adopted Roll Call 364
Motion to Adopt - Adopted Roll Call 363 9JJGIMB-1
Judiciary Engrossed Substitute Offered 9JJGIMB-1
Third Reading in House of Origin
Read for the Second Time and placed on the Calendar
Reported Out of Committee House of Origin from House Judiciary 9JJGIMB-1
Judiciary 2nd Amendment JPPZPFN-1
Judiciary 1st Amendment EJJ1A92-1
Judiciary 1st Substitute AC3Z77S-1
Pending House Judiciary
Read for the first time and referred to the House Committee on Judiciary
Room 325 at 08:30:00
Room 325 at 08:30:00
Room 200 at 13:30:00
Room 200 at 14:30:00
Room 200 at 14:30:00
Source: Alabama Legislature